Metal fans: What is the greatest metal band of all time in your opinion?
In my opinion, Metallica and Pantera are the greatest.
- BettyLv 78 months ago
- Huh?Lv 78 months ago
In terms of musical legacy and influence, Black Sabbath.
In terms of being my favourite metal band: the mighty Motörhead.
- RichardLv 68 months ago
I agree with your opinion
- 8 months ago
Alice In Chains
To name a few
- What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
- 8 months ago
I mean, there are probably a hundred metal bands I'd prefer to listen to, but you asked for 'the greatest', so I gave an honest answer.
Consider this: If somebody claimed to be a 'huge metalhead', and had never heard any of the classic Black Sabbath, Judas Priest, Slayer, Iron Maiden (so on, so forth) albums in their entirety, it would be like "Oh, they're pretty good, mate! I recommend a listen."
Now, if somebody had never listened to every single 80's Metallica album and didn't know every single lyric by heart and didn't secretly think Metallica was 19 times better than Megadeth (but never admitted to it, by God), then would you really have any respect for that person?
- AndrewLv 78 months ago
My favourite band of all time is Mercyful Fate, with King Diamond being a fairly close second. Rounding out the top 5 would be Black Sabbath, Judas Priest and Iron Maiden.
But "the greatest" and "my favourite" are two very different things. Black Sabbath, Judas Priest and Iron Maiden are the greatest Heavy Metal bands of all time. It's not up to me or you to decide that, it's simply a fact. They're the three most innovative, most influential and most iconic Heavy Metal bands in the history of the genre, end of story. Metallica released some good records, possibly even a great one, but they've never been consistent in terms of quality or style and they haven't released an album that might even be considered mediocre for almost 30 years, never mind a great record, so to suggest that they deserve to be anywhere near the top of the list is laughable. Every band has one or two clunkers - Sabbath, Priest and Maiden included, but Metallica doesn't have a legacy anywhere near as legendary.
To propose that Pantera might somehow qualify to make it on to the list of even the 100 greatest metal bands of all time is just a ridiculous statement. They were a shitty glam band for years, then decided to brand themselves as some sort of Texas hardcore - thrash hybrid, a formula that served them well on "Cowboys From Hell", but got old very quickly. All their songs sound the same, they showed zero progression or growth musically and their records are rubbish compared to heaps of other bands.
Metallica and Pantera are safe, friendly, approachable, non-threatening bands whose fan base primarily consists of blokes under 25 who take comfort in the easily digestible and simplistic songs they churn out, chaps who aren't mature enough to appreciate the talent demonstrated by bands like Amorphis for example.
To be "the greatest", you can't just be a band that a few people like. You've got to be a band that defines an era, that spurred on 10,000 other bands to follow in your footsteps, a band that other musicians point to and say "We wouldn't be here if it weren't for them."
Metal would be doing just as well as it is now if Metallica or Pantera had never existed. But without the Big Three, it wouldn't have gone anywhere.
- Robert JLv 78 months ago
Black Sabbath; no others come close.
- ch3m15tryLv 58 months ago
Agalloch, may not even be true but i've a mistycal connction with them. Altar of Plagues, also (currently, Agalloch are at the beginning, like Metallica first five albums, all of Tool, only Opiate is not a masterpiece for me, but it's still nice). In a while the new Blut aus Nord comes out and I hope it brings their back to being my favorites (last album was their worst). Candlemass. Bathory. Entombed. Carcass.
- phatzwaveLv 78 months ago
- Anonymous8 months ago
Yes I am a good model