Why isn't the "Y" considered a vowel?
- JimLv 75 months ago
Who is to consider? When you ask about "consider," you are asking about opinion. There is no authority in the US or UK to regulate English. France has Académie française, and Spain has Real Academia Española, but there is nothing like that for English.
Vowels are sounds. The way they are written in a language is another matter.
I know you were taught that Pluto is a planet and also that the vowels are a, e, i, o, u and sometimes y, but that is not true.
Depending on the dialect, English has about 14 vowels and they are written in a variety of ways.
Many letters are used in English to represent these sounds.
As you can see, w, h, y, and l are combined with other letters to represent English vowel SOUNDS. The last word is redundant, but I add it for emphasis.
There are systems to write English phonetically, but they are cumbersome.
- JosephLv 65 months ago
Sometimes it is, as in 'monkey'.
- PhillipLv 45 months ago
It varies by language and the way it sounds in the word.
- 5 months ago
It is considered a vowel, phonetically at least. Phonologically only sometimes and the reason is: a phonological vowel is at the center or peak of a syllable but Y is only sometimes in this positon.
- What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
- CatherineLv 75 months ago
It depends the countries. In France Y is a vowel and too, a half vowel. Like when we say the word ' yeux ' for example, which means eyes in English .....
- 5 months ago
Sometimes Y doesn't want to play along. It suffers from Irritable Vowel Syndrome.
- Mike WLv 75 months ago
In English Y acts as a vowel at the end of a word or syllable. Maybe they don't consider it to be a vowel, because it also acts as a consonant. One thing to consider is that Y wasn't always a letter in the English alphabet. It wasn't used in Old English, and only started to be used in Middle English.
- LônLv 75 months ago
It IS in Welsh.
Welsh has more vowels than English.
A, E, I, O ,U, W, Y.
- Chi girlLv 75 months ago
It is. Vowels: a, e, i, o, u -- and sometimes y.
- rustbucketLv 65 months ago
It gets used much less as a vowel then a consonant.